I read a post a little while ago about a woman who received criticism for allowing her 6 year old daughter to choose colorful, outlandish outfits to wear in public, even to school. Her clothing choices weren't inappropriate in any way. They didn't restrict movement or break any societal rules, like... she wasn't wearing a bathrobe and a batman mask to kindergarten or anything. She picked things like rainbow knee socks and fluffy tutus. People told the mom, "You're making things hard on her by encouraging her to stand out." And also, "It's your job to do everything you can to protect her from being ridiculed."
This happens a lot during a young person's life.
When mommy and daddy tell their daughter not to dye their hair blue, get pierced, choose not to participate in school sponsored activities, listen to such dark music, make such dark artwork, be so loud about anti-racist point of views in the middle of Mississippi, date African American boys, hold hands with girls, read banned books, become an atheist, whatever. (Can you tell I'm being auto-biographical?)
Those things, for the most part, aren't forbidden out of a sense of animosity. Parents don't want their kids to make unpopular choices out of a feeling of love. And also, mostly, a feeling of fear.
We love our kids and we want to protect them. We're actually required to protect them. It's part of our job as parents. However, we have the equally important job of deciding what to protect our children from.
All too often, we push our fears and limitations onto our children in the name of protecting them. When your daughter decides she wants to wear rainbow toe socks and a tutu to the playground, there's no actual danger involved in letting her do those things. You might be afraid that other parents will look at you funny, or that another child might question your daughter's choices. I mean, so what?
When your 8th grader decides she wants blue hair, or that she suddenly identifies with a music and fashion scene that seems strange to you... why are you really discouraging it? What are you afraid is going to happen to your child? She might not be well liked? She might be criticized or judged? Is that really HER problem, or a problem built into a flawed society that is full of sickness and meanness?
Should we really endeavor to change our children, to suppress their imaginations and senses of self-expression so that nobody will take a second glance at them, or challenge them to stand up for the things they believe in? I don't get it. What is that really teaching them?
Our children must be small and mild and neutral and agreeable. After all, we want them to be accepted, right? We want them to have an easy life, right? We don't want them to have to go through the torture of being different.
What about the torture of feeling like you can't be who you believe you really are, inside? What about when your parents, who are supposed to support you and encourage you, no matter what, suddenly side with a bunch of strangers and give them the power to decide how you should look, what you should care about and enjoy, and who you should love?
What about the fact that kids who choose to shove themselves down inside, who comply, who have an easy life and the approval of everybody? What happens when those kids wake up one morning and they're 30 years old and they feel sad all the time, but they don't know why? They feel like, despite growing up and achieving the things they were supposed to achieve, they have no idea who they really are. They lived in a way that made everybody happy. They didn't make unpopular choices, they didn't push any limits or break any invisible rules. They wake up and find out that they have no passion and no bravery and no real reason to keep being themselves.
It seems to me that our kids are people. They're not us. They're also not just a piece of society that we should manipulate and make decisions for. They have their own thoughts, their own tastes, their own ideas. Instead of trying to mold our children into something that will allow them to glide through an existence in a crappy world full of crappy people who believe stupid things, we should encourage our kids to be what they want to be, who they believe they really are. Maybe if they're big enough and bright enough and brave enough, it won't even matter to them that a bunch of stupid people think they're weird or unacceptable. Maybe they'll even be able to become something decidedly NOT STUPID and help other people to be less afraid to tell the truth about who they are, too.
It's my job as a parent to protect my kids from harm. There are so many harmful ways of thinking being shoved down everybody's throats all the time. I consider it my duty to try as hard as I can to help my daughters build a solid sense of self, to love who they really believe they are, so that they'll thrive in spite of, or maybe even because of the opposition of a mindless society full of boring, pointless conditions.
-
I am the mom of a 5 year old like that. I was the only mom in her class that let her dress herself and I always felt bad for all those perfect looking children.
ReplyDeleteXavier starting to have understandable opinions and preferences about things, so we like to ask him what he thinks about stuff.
ReplyDeleteRecently, I asked him to tell me his favorite color. He said, "Pink!" rather proudly. I'm guessing a lot of dads would be dismayed about that, but whatever... pink is a nice color, and it's kind of cool to me that he didn't choose a really obvious color like red.
He also really loves "The Bubbleguppies," which is a pretty goofy, somewhat educational show on Nick Jr. Sometimes he walks around the house, telling us we're characters from the show. Avy and I are often different characters, but he almost always chooses to be Molly, one of main characters who sings the lead on a lot of the songs. Not surprisingly, she has pink hair. Again, I think a lot of dads would be somewhat upset that their little boy is identifying with a female character so strongly.
This doesn't bother me any more than when he decides to be Buddy from "Dinosaur Train"--in fact, it's pretty much the same thing.
I get why he thinks Molly and Buddy are so cool--they're the characters that get the most screen time, and they often drive the plot of the whole episode... Of course he likes them! I'm glad he doesn't choose his heroes by gender...
Right now, he doesn't have too much of an opinion about clothes--although I think he'd probably wear his "Mater" shirt all the time if he could. I kind of wonder what he'll want to wear when he starts to care about that.
I also wonder what he'll want to do with his hair--he's never had a haircut, and we don't do anything much with his hair besides giving him the occasional ponytail. I think Avy and I would both feel like total hypocrites if we insisted on some kind of haircut or style, so we're just going to let him decide what he wants to do with his head. We will probably not allow piercings (other than ears) until he's 15, and tattoos will be a reward for good grades... that is, if he even wants tattoos or piercings. Who knows what people will come up with in body modifications in the future?
Basically, we want him to make his own decisions... I mean, we'll be there to offer advice if he wants it, but, for the most part, I think we want to provide him with basic facts about stuff and let him make up his own mind about stuff. The only thing I don't want to do is pay a lot of money for trendy fashions... I don't mind him wearing those types of things, but I think if he wants something especially expensive, he's going to have to save his pennies to get it. I'm pretty sure he's going to think I am a bastard for that...
For the most part, I agree with your viewpoint here. I didn't have a child to create a carbon copy of myself. I can't wait to discover who she is. If that means she wears "strange" clothes and thick black eyeliner one day, then I will celebrate that as much as anything else.
ReplyDeleteThe only area where I differ is with piercings (and tattoos). Olivia will not have permission to pierce anything beyond her ears or tattoo anything before she turns 18. Not because I want to control her appearance or protect her from the judgement of society, but because I want her to be as adult as possible before choosing to make a permanent change to her body. I've known too many people who later in life have sincerely regretted the tattoos they have gotten as a young person.
Stacy, well, that's exactly in line with what I'm talking about. It's your job to protect your girl, and you don't want her to make permanent changes to her body before she's ready to really understand what she's doing. I don't think I would endorse my girls getting tattoos, either, until they're legally able to make that choice for themselves. If they were of age and making the decision totally on their own, I would never discourage them from getting one because I know that people think they're not professional or whatever.
ReplyDeleteThere's nothing wrong with guiding your kids to make good decisions. There is something wrong with making decisions for them based out a of fear of being disagreed with or judged by society.
My parents never discouraged me from being different - but they made it hard for me, that's for sure! When I told them I wanted to dye my hair blue in the 7th grade, they said sure - then shipped me off for three weeks to my Grandparents to live with them in their small town. I got a lot of stares, a lot of whispers. I knew exactly how standing out was hard. But I was damn proud of my blue hair and have had nearly every colour since then!
ReplyDeleteI like to think that when Des is old enough to make these kinds of choices, I'll be right there to help him navigated those crazy feelings when you know you might not fit in.
Just to be clear... I am not in any way saying that I think everybody should endorse every whim their children have, regarding themselves. I'm not pro-tattoo or pro-piercing or anything. I'm just saying that... if you're encouraging your kids to be something other than what they believe they are because you're scared they'll be judged, you should examine your motives and try to decide if the "danger" of not being accepted is really a danger.
ReplyDeleteI think it's fantastic that you're encouraging your children to discover who they are rather than worry about what everyone else thinks. I bet the other girls in class love her tutus and rainbow stockings!
ReplyDeleteGreat post!! I admit that both of my children have on occassion gotten stared at for wearing some interesting outfits of their choosing . . . particularly when my 1.5 yr old wore his sister's clip on earings to school . . . but that is their choice and it is not going to hurt them.
ReplyDeleteJenn
You are an excellent writer. I think you hit the nail on the head when you say that people act from a sense of fear.
ReplyDeleteI'm going to play devil's advocate for just a moment here... and you KNOW I LOVE your writing and think you are completely awesome so I hope you won't be offended. I've thought lots about your cheerleader post... and while I completely agree that boy was WAY out of line and certainly don't want my daughter treated like a piece of meat, imagine for one second that you DO raise Scouty to have a strong sense of self and someone who stands up for herself and what she believes in (which you will)... but then one day she comes to you and wants to try out for cheerleading. What would you do? My SIL was SO opposed to the whole "princess" thing, and no pink, and no girly girly stuff, which I totally get... but she went SO overboard about it. And then guess what? My two nieces are the girliest little princesses you have ever met, because really that's just who they are... To me, being a good parent is about protecting your kids and accepting WHOEVER they are... and some kids just really DO want be cheerleaders or princesses. Some of our dear friends have a SON who just became the first male cheerleader at our very large suburban high school...not exactly a popular choice where most boys play baseball or football. I LOVE LOVE LOVE that they have supported him 100% in achieving his dream... and I LOVE LOVE LOVE that I know you are going to do the same for your girls, no matter who they want to be.
ReplyDeleteGood writing as always and a great topic.
ReplyDeleteBoth my daughters dressed as they liked, in their personal time, as the schools they attended had dress codes that were enforced.
Pierced ears where fine, as well as dyed hair, but tattoos were an 18 and over choice.
I was more concerned on what was going on in the inside, that they had good hearts, and strong minds.
That they were objective, yet sensible. Common sense goes a long way in this crazy world, and I tried to plant that tiny little voice in their minds that asks "is this the right thing to do". If you ask me if I succeeded, well the vote may still be out, but I am fairly confident.
Outside appearances mean little in the long haul.
As parents we just hope that our children become good adults, and if they so choose good parents.
Yes! "Crappy people who believe stupid things"! I had a really tough time in school after my parents moved us across the country (the LAMEST thing that happened to me growing up, sorry, but it totally was). Kids were brutal, but I found my own path and though I did lots of stupid things, I'm also here at 31 kind of on a good track and with the best education of all of my siblings, who were much less wild.
ReplyDeleteSo you're right, we don't need to protect our children from creepy people who believe stupid things, I think what we really, truly need to do is help kids find their passion in life. I've been free enough and uninhibited enough to find several. You rule, Amanda!!!
Correction!!! We do need to protect children from creepy people, but not shelter them from "crappy people who believe stupid things". And Fox in the City, that is so cute!
ReplyDelete