Tuesday, October 2, 2012

My happiness intentions better defined, with the help of a brilliant man who killed himself.

Yes.  A friend brought this famous speech by David Foster Wallace to my attention, today.  It is so on point with everything I've been thinking about happiness lately.  Please read it, if you're not already familiar with it.

It might seem weird that I'm bringing up David Foster Wallace in the context of happiness.  Hopefully, it won't.  Because when I say that I am going to try to be happy, I don't mean the kind of happiness on cereal commercials, where you've been eating nothing but cereal for weeks, and you can finally look down at the scale and say, "Yes!"  I'm not talking about the kind of happiness that makes you strut around in a pair of heels.  I'm not talking about the kind of happiness that says, "I'm sorry, but I'm going to be happy no matter what it takes."

What I'm actually talking about when I say that I want to be happy is that I want to live a life full of meaning.  I want to live in a way where I'm not viewing everyone around me as an inconvenience or an accessory to my life.  I want to be the kind of happy that says, "Deep down inside, I believe that I am making the world a better place, simply by being alive."  I want the sort of happiness that comes from choosing to not be alone on my own island of better existence.  I want the sort of happiness that comes from seeking extrinsic goals, from actively choosing and working to reject the idea that a smaller body or more stuff, or a cleaner house, or flattering clothes will make me happier.

Some people will say, "What did David Foster Wallace know about happiness or living a good life?  He killed himself."

I believe that what he knew about happiness is that it is a lot of work.  In this speech, he said:

"The point is that petty, frustrating crap like this is exactly where the work of choosing comes in. Because the traffic jams and crowded aisles and long checkout lines give me time to think, and if I don't make a conscious decision about how to think and what to pay attention to, I'm going to be pissed and miserable every time I have to food-shop, because my natural default-setting is the certainty that situations like this are really all about me, about my hungriness and my fatigue and my desire to just get home, and it's going to seem, for all the world, like everybody else is just in my way, and who are all these people in my way? And look at how repulsive most of them are and how stupid and cow-like and dead-eyed and nonhuman they seem here in the checkout line, or at how annoying and rude it is that people are talking loudly on cell phones in the middle of the line, and look at how deeply unfair this is: I've worked really hard all day and I'm starved and tired and I can't even get home to eat and unwind because of all these stupid g-d- people."
He goes on to talk about how we can choose to hate everyone for being so stupid, or we can consider where they might have come from.  The asshole in an SUV who is cutting everyone off in traffic might be trying desperately to get the hospital where his son is dying.  It might not be likely, but it is possible, and who are we to decide what is true for the people around us?  Are we really so arrogant that the only reason somebody might be behaving in a way we find annoying is because they're stupid idiots who are inconveniencing us? 

Haven't we ever behaved in a way that other people might have hated?  When we're stuck in road work traffic and it's getting later and later and we're supposed to be picking our four year old little girl at preschool in five minutes and there's no way we're going to make it on time, and she's going to be scared and disappointed, and we start beeping and swearing and driving like a maniac... all anybody knows about us is that we're an asshole driver, right?

The kind of happiness I'm looking for is the kind that doesn't assume that everyone else is an asshole.  Do you see the difference?  I'm not aiming for those last 5 pounds of yes!  I am aiming for a state of mind where I'm not the only thing that matters, because being the only thing is isolating and lonely and it makes brilliant, beautiful people shove knives through their ribcages.  Being the only thing makes us unhappy and sick.  It erodes away our bones, hardens our arteries, deadens our skin and makes us cry.  Being the only thing hurts, and it is at the heart of unhappiness.

Someone commented on my last post, "This post made me laugh because just last week I was just listening to my Anthropology teacher talk about how it is very American to 'try and be happy.'"

I hated this comment.  I found it unbelievably condescending and presumptuous.  But then, I thought about how we don't even know what we mean by "happiness," anymore.  How, believing that we need to keep working to upgrade ourselves and our possessions, that if we just keep working hard and trying, we can achieve that Special K yes! kind of happiness, which isn't actually happiness at all.  That is probably a pretty "American" thing to do.

I think that we're probably just not talking about the same thing.  I think that teachers who scoff at anybody's attempt to live with meaning and achieve happiness, probably choose to think about how ugly and stupid and annoying people are.  I think that people in happy parts of the world aren't annoying to these teachers, and Americans with their cars and $200 jeans and SUVs are... and that these teachers aren't seeing either group as being human beings with their own truths about existing, and that no matter what your truth is, it's been a lot of work.

I guess I might say to this teacher:

The next time you roll your eyes and point out that if we lived in a remote village in Thailand, we wouldn't have to "try and be happy," maybe you'll think about this.  Maybe you'll think about how the act of waking up in America is sponsored, how, in the land of opportunity, there are companies, right now who are plotting ways to get you to spend money on the act of breathing, how our self-esteem and belief in what it means to be acceptable is sold to us, you might not be so likely to scoff at the effort it takes to be happy, in a society where companies hire scientists to peck away at ways to manipulate you, and sell you a new version of yourself that you can't attain, because it isn't you. 

What does it mean to be sold a new version of yourself?  It means that no matter who you are, you could be better.  No matter what you've accomplished, you are still not good enough.  It means that you feel powerless and flaccid.  It means that, by default, you hate yourself and believe yourself incapable of making decisions about your body, health and happiness.

It also means that corporations are waiting with their arms out to comfort you and provide relief against the desperation they, themselves have have created for you.  They build faulty structures you can prop yourself against, to keep your face out of the mud, to keep suicide at bay, to convince you to keep trying to buy salvation.  They teach you that you are a failure, but they also perpetuate the myth that it's your fault.  They tell you to keep trying... you are simply a temporarily embarrassed version of a better you.  You are perpetually one membership, diet, rack of clothing and meal at Subway away from happiness. 

Happiness research suggests that, once our basic needs are met, having more of anything, especially money, doesn't actually make us any happier.  That is a hard pill to swallow, as an American.  That someone who lives in a two room bamboo structure and gardens and fishes to survive could be as happy as we are with our cars and homes and delivery pizza and giant televisions. 

Americans have to work at happiness because society is actively working against their happiness.  Society is profiting from their unhappiness.  Society is built on the faulty belief that more money, more possessions, more opportunity for growth, more status and more acceptance will equal more happiness.  Waking up in the morning and not giving into the temptation to hate what we see in the mirror is an act of unabashed bravery.  It has gotten to the point for many women that EATING FOOD is an act of bravery.  That walking around in the world in their own bodies takes courage and will beyond anything we could imagine.

Americans have to work at happiness because eating food is scary to us.  Having just enough money to feed our families and fuel our cars and make payments on our possessions and pay for cable and internet and eating out at a restaurant only once or twice a month is scary to us!  Not having money and possessions squirreled away for an imagined future threat is scary to us!  Nobody is scared of the fact that we hate ourselves and we view everybody around us as an annoying obstacle to our fearful, depressive existence.  Being an American, or a citizen of any highly industrialized society, probably, means that our default setting, thanks to a lifetime of being bought and sold, is isolated, scared and always seeking more.

When I say that I want to be happy, I mean that I want to pass people on the street and see them.  I want to be able to say, "I acknowledge that you are more than an inconvenience to me, and I love you in my own small way for being whatever you are.  Because I am human, I know that you've been through a lot of shit, to get to where you are and to become what you've become.  I don't want to pass judgement on you, because I know that you're lonely and scared and feel like you're lacking, just like me."

I don't want to be mad and in a hurry all the time.  I don't want to weigh myself.  I don't want to be afraid of breakfast.  I don't want to stare at a screen full of meaningless crap all day.  I don't want to stockpile a hoard of fear around me.  I want to be happy because I love the world and want it to be an okay place.  I want to be happy because I want to mean something.  That's why I'm trying.


-

18 comments:

  1. "I want to be happy because I love the world and want it to be an okay place."

    Or, and, be happy because you love the world and it IS an okay place.

    Because perception is everything.

    This post was touching. ((hugs))

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think that David Foster Wallace probably knew a great deal about happiness. Whether he was able to achieve the ideal or not is irrelevant to whether or not the advice is good. It's sad he couldn't be happy. It's awesome that even after he is gone, he can perhaps helps others.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I love your passion, and love the fact that you say outloud what a lot of us are only brave enouogh to admit to admit to our closest circle. I to am on a journey to connect and see the world differently. You are inspiring, I seek Joy, and I see Joy rising in you with your passion, and letting go of fear...

    ReplyDelete
  4. I love your passion, and love the fact that you say outloud what a lot of us are only brave enouogh to admit to admit to our closest circle. I to am on a journey to connect and see the world differently. You are inspiring, I seek Joy, and I see Joy rising in you with your passion, and letting go of fear...

    ReplyDelete
  5. Did you ever read The Happiness Project? It was transformative. Getting outside yourself, as you (and DFW) mention in this post is really an interesting exercise-or even so far inside yourself that you don't consider what anyone out there is doing or feeling at all. Both methods serve to remove me from my obsession with my own comfort. You'd think that the latter would do the opposite, but when I stop thinking about the surface stuff at all: who's being a dick on the road, how long I've been standing here, how long it's been since I've had a cup of coffee and how many people are left in the line- I'm free to consider other shit. Like the book in my hand or the song on the radio. You know?

    ReplyDelete
  6. I read this, and then read it again. There's a lot here for me to think about, but it feels very...true. I'm tired of wasting all my attention on the surface of my skin: my body, my uncooperative skin, my crow's feet, my frizzy hair. I've so bought into the idea that my appearance as it measures up to an ideal somehow can bring me closer to happiness (because it's entirely within my control, the magazines tell me), and while I've known for a while now that can't be true, I haven't been able to articulate what I *really* want.

    I think what I want is what you've touched on here: I would like my attention turned outward and inward. I would like to stop looking at surfaces. I would like to trust and I would like to open instead of close.

    You may have just changed me a little bit - thank you

    ReplyDelete
  7. I was feeling like shit last night. I was at work - I work with a ton of early 20-somethings - and last night they were being particularly obnoxious. A couple of girls asked me to go out with them on Saturday night but couldn't even get the question out without laughing. Another co-worker told me I could play the part of Nanny McPhee. Plus there was all the touching and discussion that comes with being pregnant that I am getting so incredibly burned out on. I feel like *I* have disappeared and am merely seen as an incubator. An old, ugly incubator that people compare to Nanny McPhee and make jokes about hanging out with outside of work. When I got home, my intention was to go online and buy the beautiful pink lace maternity dress I wanted to wear for our maternity pictures. I found out that it was no longer for sale on that website (or any website, really) and it really upset me. It's just a dress but I had spent some time thinking of myself wearing it and being beautiful; I had high hopes of being captured at this most special time in my life and looking back on those pictures and marveling at how beautiful and happy I was. I haven't felt very beautiful during this pregnancy. I haven't felt very beautiful for much of my life, if I can be completely honest.

    When I read DFW's speech early this morning, something clicked for me, though I can't even really begin to say what, just that what I read felt (feels) extremely important, like something I need to hang onto. Life is hard, so unbearably hard at times. It's important that we love hard, work hard, and play hard. It's important that we write and sing and dance and listen to music and make art and make love and cry. It's important to recognize that everything that matters most is utterly fragile, able to dissolve in an instant. That includes ourselves - our TRUE selves.

    I think empathy is at the center of happiness. I think empathy is the greatest gift we can give to others - and to ourselves.

    Thanks for this post. I am completely incoherent as usual but wanted you to know that I feel what you're saying.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Oh, Leslie. Your comment brought tears to my eyes. I feel that way all the time. Like I'm just a big, ugly, stupid joke... but really inside I know I can move mountains.

    I just wanted to say that I love you. I don't know you, so maybe that's weird. I have things for certain people for different reasons. Not very often, but sometimes someone will impress me as being one of the most beautiful things alive, and you're one of them.

    For whatever that's worth.

    ReplyDelete
  9. "The kind of happiness I'm looking for is the kind that doesn't assume that everyone else is an asshole."

    That sounds like a good place to start, considering it sounds like you immediately jumped to the conclusion that I, a daily (and supportive) reader, was being rude and condescending.

    I'd say you pretty much proved my Anthropology teacher's point right here in this post, in regards to American lifestyle and how that changes up the "happiness" factor. Other, more primitive cultures, are confused when asked "Has your life been a happy one?" They consistently answer that sometimes they've been happy, and sometimes they've been sad, and sometimes they've been lots of other things. The next portion of her lecture is transcribed here. I think it's beautiful.

    “American culture denies the kind of pain that's inevitable in human lives. We tend to feel that if we just eat right, keep fit, and keep good thoughts in our head that we can avoid the inevitable pain of human life. In fact, we kind of deny it's inevitable, but everybody is going to die. We don't like to think about it too much. In fact, we don't really believe it. People we love will die while we stay alive and that will be horrible. People we love will leave us and won't love us back. Our bodies will fall apart, our bodies will betray us, our babies will be born and they'll die at birth…Pain is inevitable in human life. Modern science can't remove it, can't delete it. It's always going to be there; science can't eliminate the pain of human life. Certainly that's something that many other cultures are more aware of than we are. We're so intoxicated with the power of our extremely powerful technology that we have forgotten that there are human aspects of life that nothing can fix.”

    ReplyDelete
  10. I see so much truth in this! It wasn't until the day that my grandfather died and I was driving home crying, probably totally all over the road, and a guy was so mad at me that he flipped me off that I realized that all those people I was mad at while driving, they could have just lost their grandpa too.

    Anyone could be hurting or in pain and acting out of that. We all hurt, we all experience loss, and everyone has a story.

    I really believe all anyone ever really needs is to tell their story and to feel heard.

    I am far from perfect at remembering this but it does help so much - seeing the world in this way.

    I wish you so much meaningful happiness on this journey. :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. Rae, I didn't watch the Sopranos, but my husband did and he told me that a Russian character once said something like, "Americans are the only ones who expect that their lives should be happy." That Americans are the only people arrogant enough to believe they deserve happiness. Or something along those lines. That's what your comment today reminded me of. It's an interesting perspective.

    I'm sorry that I've offended you.

    Can I tell you what I really think happened in this exchange? I think that you felt superior to me the other day, and laughed at me, because you perceived what I was saying as being banal. Then, I wrote this post, using the fact that you laughed at me as a springboard for my thoughts. What I said today embarrassed you, so now you're backtracking, and trying to paint your original comment in a better light.

    If this is all honestly, totally off base, then you are right. Trying to assume better of people is a wonderful place for me to start. It's a wonderful place for me to start, anyway. I don't think you are an asshole, even if you really were letting me know that you were laughing at me.

    I didn't mean to alienate you, by highlighting your comment. I honestly thought that, since you were convicted enough to write it in the first place, you wouldn't be hurt by me acknowledging it. I have to admit, as evidenced by my reply to your original comment, that I was surprised by your criticism. You have been supportive and I've noticed that over time, so thank you.







    ReplyDelete
  12. Daniegirl, yes. And maybe they didn't just lose their grandpa, but who am I to assume that? I don't know anything about anybody else's life and history, except that... I know mine, and that we're all trying our best. One little thing I do know is that I am not simply an inconvenience in somebody else's life. I am hugely more than that, and so must everybody else be, to me.

    Thank you for leaving me a comment. Your thoughts really touched me. <3

    ReplyDelete
  13. Jessie, yes. I agree with you, totally.

    Do you listen to Elliott Smith at all? He was a beautiful, brilliant person who killed himself, too. The other day I read an essay by somebody who was mad at him. They said that all of his songs about sadness were practically masturbation, if the point of them wasn't to try to overcome the sadness.

    I felt the same way you said about DFW. Just because he didn't manage to overcome the sadness, didn't mean he wasn't for real about intending to.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Summer, I did read it! I wanted to love it, but I don't know. Gretchen Rubin's life and attitude were just a little unrelatable to me. I loved the idea of taking a systematic approach to gaining happiness, though. While cleaning out my closet doesn't quite get me there, her idea is brilliant, and is totally the inspiration for my own happiness endeavors.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Megan, THANK YOU for leaving me this comment. You have no idea how much it touches me to hear about your struggles, how they're just like mine.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I wanted to check in again and say, first of all, thank you for your comment back to me. It's not weird to tell me you love me. I love you, too. I really appreciate what you've said here.

    I also think Rae (and her teacher) have offered an interesting perspective. It's certainly something I've noticed when I've written about painful things in my life. People want to gloss over it with cliches and trite expressions, and you can't gloss over pain, not the real kind. I also think that Americans perhaps ARE hugely arrogant in our relentless feelings of entitlement (I shudder to use that word due to its political implications) towards happiness. We do tend to think that if we do everything right, or even if we don't, that happiness will be ours, instead of embracing the fact that we are where we are and where we are isn't always the happiest place on earth. Or happy at all. Disneyland calls itself "the happiest place on earth" - it's probably no coincidence that it costs at least $87 bucks for an adult to gain admission.

    Rae's perspective goes hand in hand with one of my absolute favorite blog posts on marriage: http://poemsandnovels.blogspot.com/2012/08/the-meaning-of-married-scenes-from.html

    Maybe it's time for a perspective shift from the desire for happiness to a reach towards acceptance. Maybe empathy really isn't at the core of happiness like I said earlier. Maybe I really don't know shit about shit, and maybe that's okay.

    My head is swimming. In a good way.

    ReplyDelete
  17. You move me. You do.
    I've been thinking about happiness, too. Here I am, after three years of being profoundly unhappy, with all the ingredients for happiness: sun, warmth, family, friends, community, excitement, adventure. Yet, still, I keep wandering in my mind, and asking myself, is it all meaningless. Are the words I write on my blog empty? Is the desire to beautify my new apartment vapid? This fancy dinner, that beautiful outfit, that website. I'm living here, in this country where some people don't even have shoes, where I pay someone 3x the market rate to help me with my kid, and it's still peanuts. So what does it matter, these clothes, this bag, this house? Is everything just a Nietzscheian illusion?
    What I've come up with is two things: beauty and kindness.
    I'm going to be seeking out beauty. Beauty matters to me. Beauty matters to most people, even those who do not have shoes, they sweep their floor, place objects just so, and try to make things look nice. I can strive for beauty and feel that it is real and true.

    Kindness matters too. You wrote, "When I say that I want to be happy, I mean that I want to pass people on the street and see them. I want to be able to say, "I acknowledge that you are more than an inconvenience to me, and I love you in my own small way for being whatever you are. " I think this is about community and kindess. Knowing someone is true, is a human, has a spirt, seeing that, and loving that. Well, that's central. I lived three years without a community and was so empty and sad. Now, I have one and it almost made me giddy to find that. Humanity matters, connection matters, community and kindess are true.

    I'll strive for those things, beauty and kindess, and community. If nothing else is real, at least those things are. And they may not lead to happiness, per se, but contentedness. And I think that's wonderful.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I just wanted to say that I totally get this, I totally want this.

    I know people who sortof shit sunshine all around them, in a completely fake "LALALA LIFE IS GREAT ISN'T IT? THERE ARE NO PROBLEMS AT ALL. WE WON'T TALK ABOUT THE PROBLEMS."

    I feel like some variation on this is how Rae interpreted your original post, but that's totally not. it.

    I don't think pursuing happiness is an American pursuit, I think its a human pursuit. We all want sunshine.
    I think what you're going for -- and what I'm going for, too -- is a genuine, rooted, and wise happiness. It's not a fake kind. It's a wrinkled, imperfect, more beautiful and whole kind of happiness.

    I found this post from one of the blogs you link to, and I think it is spot on.
    http://fillyourwell.blogspot.com/2011/08/4-questions.html

    Plus I read this today:
    http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/28/magazine/the-island-where-people-forget-to-die.html?pagewanted=all&_r=3&

    Plus, there's this, from the Buddha:
    “When you realize how perfect everything is you will tilt your head back and laugh at the sky”

    And there's this, from Regina Spektor:

    “The other day I was down by the Hudson River, and I see two nuns in full habit rollerblading down the street holding hands. And I’m like, ‘Oh, my God, I get it. The world is surreal and beautiful and everything is fine."

    ReplyDelete